Review topics: ["irritation","quality","color","problem","feels","design","texture","lines","packaging","amount","formula","shipping","skin","look","eyes","use","shade","customer service","container","works","face","complexion","effect","eyeliner","brush","application","stays","pencil","lasting","mystikol"].
Reviews
Best Eyeliner Ever
"The best gel eyeliner on the market! Fabulous dark purple, smooth texture, and easy applicator - my go-to for years! I've tried other eyeliner but none are a smooth and long lasting as Mystikol. I put my makeup on at 7 a. m. , work all day, go shopping, and at 7 p. m. , my eyeliner looks the same as when applied that morning!"
— Wendi B. (5/5)
Best Eye Makeup
"I have had issues with eye makeup causing irritation to my eyes for years. I’ve used very expensive brands, drug store brands, non allergenic brands nothing worked. I get red irritated eyes until I take off the makeup. I finally discovered Jane Airedale eye makeup. No irritation! I cannot believe it. I purchased eye liner, and mascara and it looks great. After so many years of either not using eye makeup or suffering with sore irritated eyes, I can finally look good and no irritation! Thank you - you have a loyal customer!"
— Mary G. (5/5)
Pretty Color
"Pretty color, but is too subtle and doesn't stay put. Too expensive not to deliver."
— Sheryl T. (3/5)
Just okay
"Customer service is 10/10. The eyeliner said it was good for waterline, and its just so so. Kinda flaky. Great for lid lining though."
— Kellye P. (3/5)
Very disappointed with Mystikol Eyeliner
"This was an absolute waste of money. I am a huge fan of all your products but this just does not work. It smudges so quickly and does not stay at all! Very disappointed"
— rachna v. (1/5)
I love this as it
"I love this as it goes on smooth and makes my hazel eyes really stand out. It is also easy to apply and does not smudge plus I like that it can look soft and natural or applied thicker I can get a more smokey look."
— Maria B. (5/5)
Says it won’t transfer. Well
"Says it won’t transfer. Well it does. And my lids are not oily, believe me. I have dry skin. I also don’t put moisturizer on my lids"
— Teresa S. (1/5)
Eye liner
"I like the way this eyeliner goes on and stays on. iI like the creamy feeling."
— Kathleen G. (5/5)
Very Controllable & Smooth
"I have bought liquid liners for my eye lid, and they make me sweat a little when applying them. I'm able to control the application of this much better and don't have to wait for it to dry. Love it!"
— Shannon (5/5)
Wonderful Eyeliner
"It is easy to use and has staying power!"
— Sheila J. (5/5)