Search

Search

Liquid Eyeliner

  • Highly pigmented and long lasting.
  • Latex-free.
  • Essential oils nourish the skin and prevent drying.

Overall rating: 3.9186046 / 5 from 172 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

This liquid eyeliner is highly pigmented and long-lasting, with essential oils to nourish the skin and prevent drying. While it creates a precise cat eye and a nice thin line, some customers found the formula flimsy and the applicator difficult to use.

Summary topics

  • cat eye creation: 5%
  • line quality: 30%

Review topics: ["size","ingredients","irritation","problem","quality","color","feels","lines","packaging","formula","look","shipping","eyes","liquid","use","eyeliner","brush","application","jane iredale","black","reaction","stays","brown","brand","makeup","wand","chemicals","glides","batch","tip"].

Review highlights

  • "The silky smooth formula glides over the skin effortlessly making a precise line!"Lori P.
  • "It looks great, feels great and does not irritate my eyes like other brands do."LYNN L.
  • "Nice Thin line, goes on smooth, looks really clean."Amanda R.

Reviews

I love this liquid eyeliner!

"I love this liquid eyeliner! It goes on so smoothly & easy! It does not burn my eyes. The color is beautiful & stays on all day. . . not too dark and not too light. A great product! Thank you!"

Monica K. (5/5)

Miss the dark Brown Eyeliner!

"I love the liquid eyeliner but want the brown back! It was dark brown and I loved it! Used it for many years!"

Donna K. (3/5)

Liked the original better

"I’ve been using this eyeliner for years & loved it but it seems like the formula changed recently. It’s not as pigmented as it once was."

Rachel (3/5)

Liquid Eyeliner

"The liquid is easy to apply accurately with its easy to control brush."

Bernice S. (5/5)

eyeliner

"I like the eyeliner but wish you had it in the dark brown and not just black. I find the dark brown softer than the black"

Sylvia P. (5/5)

too dark

"Please please please bring back the brown eyeliner. The black is way too harsh!"

Sharon (3/5)

Almost there

"Not completely happy with the consistency of the product. Fades away too quickly. But at least I can have a back up for another brand which has discontinued their eyeliner."

Jane A. (4/5)

Great for small sensitive eyes

"Best liquid eyeliner for small eyes and not a lot of lid. This also is great for sensitive eyes."

angela k. (5/5)

Excellent Eyeliner

"I was on the hunt for a clean, liquid eyeliner, and I LOVE how thin the applicator is. It’s perfect for a sleek, precise look, but works to do a thicker line too."

Emily M. (5/5)

Very fine

"It goes on and stays on well, but/and the brush is very thin, so it’s a more subtle look. If you want drama, gotta get it somewhere else."

Adrienne N. (5/5)

Q&A

What happened to the brown/black liquid eyeliner? Black is too harsh for me! Are you bringing it back?
We only offer Black Liquid Eyeliner at this time. Perhaps you will enjoy Brown/Black Eye Pencil!
Your liquid eye liner is about the best in the biz. I’m sorry to see that it only comes in black. I’m one of those people that looks sickly in black. Please, please, please bring back the brown and eggplant/purple that you used to do. :)
Thank you for taking the time to provide your feedback! We will ensure your comments are forwarded to our Product Development team.
Any idea how soon you will have the brown-black eyeliner back on the shelf?
This shade is no longer available. We now suggest Black/Brown Eye Pencil or Dark Topaz Mystikol Powdered Eyeliner to be most comparable!
I am one of the customers who wants the return of the Brown-Black liquid eyeliner. Pencil liner is a no-go and the Mystikol is not accetble either. I've searched high and low for a good brown-black eyeliner that isn't full of nasty ingredients. I've been looking for months and so far . . . nothing!
Thank you for voicing your feedback. We will make sure it is heard by our Product Development Team. We'd like to help you find a new favorite eyeliner. Please contact us at 877-869-9420 or BeautyAdvisors@janeiredale.com.
Will you be re-considering returning a brown or brown-black LIQUID eyeliner to your offerings. Yes, I have tried Mystikol Powdered Eyeliner but it cannot draw a VERY fine line and also the application takes longer and tugs against sensitive eyelids. The Brown/brown-black may not have been a big seller, but when a customer has to go to another product line (even to find one product), that is not a satisfied customer. Can you recommend an alternative source -- just for the eyeliner? Thank you very much.
Thank you for your feedback! In place of Black/Brown Liquid Eyeliner, you can also try Black Brown Eye Pencil or a Dark Suede Eye Shadow as a liner. To do this you will gently dampen an eyeliner brush and pick up some of the eye shadow pigment and apply. It'll create a long-lasting eyeliner!